Masanin tarihi Winifred Duke ya yi iƙirarin "... yarda da ra'ayin Arba'in da Biyar a cikin zukatan mafi yawan mutane shine haɗuwa mai ban sha'awa da ban sha'awa na wasan motsa jiki da crusade ... a cikin gaskiyar sanyi, Charles ba a so kuma ba a maraba."Masu sharhi na zamani suna jayayya cewa mayar da hankali kan "Bonnie Prince Charlie" ya ɓoye gaskiyar cewa da yawa daga cikin waɗanda suka shiga Tashin Rising sun yi haka ne saboda suna adawa da Ƙungiyar, ba Hanoverians ba;wannan al'amari na kishin kasa ya sa ya zama wani bangare na ra'ayin siyasa mai ci gaba, ba aikin karshe na wata manufa da al'ada ba.Bayan 1745, sanannen ra'ayi na Highlanders ya canza daga na "wyld, wykkd Helandmen," launin fata da al'adu daban-daban daga sauran Scots, zuwa mambobin tseren jarumi masu daraja.Shekaru ɗari kafin 1745, talaucin ƙauye ya haifar da karuwar adadin don shiga cikin sojojin kasashen waje, irin su Brigade na Dutch Scots.Duk da haka, yayin da kwarewar soja kanta ta zama gama gari, bangarorin soja na dangi sun kasance suna raguwa shekaru da yawa, yaƙin tsakanin dangi na ƙarshe shine Maol Ruadh a watan Agustan 1688. An dakatar da sabis na harkokin waje a 1745 kuma an ƙara daukar ma'aikata a cikin Sojan Burtaniya kamar yadda ya dace. siyasa da gangan.Masu gudanar da mulkin mallaka na Victoria sun ɗauki manufar mayar da hankali kan daukar ma'aikata a kan abin da ake kira "jinsunan soja," an haɗa Highlanders tare da Sikhs, Dogras da Gurkhas a matsayin waɗanda aka gano ba tare da izini ba a matsayin raba halayen soja.Tashe-tashen hankula da abubuwan da suka biyo baya ya kasance abin shahara ga marubuta da dama;mafi mahimmancin waɗannan shine Sir Walter Scott, wanda a farkon karni na 19 ya gabatar da Tawaye a matsayin wani ɓangare na tarihin haɗin kai.Jarumin littafinsa Waverley Bature ne wanda ya yi gwagwarmaya don Stuarts, ya ceci Kanar Hanoverian kuma a ƙarshe ya ƙi kyakkyawan kyakkyawa Highland ga 'yar aristocrat Lowland.Sulhun Scott na Unionism da '45 sun ba wa ɗan'uwan Cumberland George IV fentin ƙasa da shekaru 70 daga baya sanye da rigar Highland da tartans, a baya alamun tawayen Jacobite.