Matsayin ƙungiyar ba shi da tabbas, kuma mutanen za su iya ganin XI Corps suna komawa daga yakin arewa, wanda yawancin ƙungiyoyin Confederates suka bi.Doubleday ya ba da umarnin janye gabas zuwa Dutsen Cemetery.^[44] A gefen kudu, brigade na North Carolina na Brig.Janar James H. Lane ya ba da gudummawa kadan ga harin;ya shagaltu da yin arangama da sojojin dawakai a kan titin Hagerstown.Brig.Janar Edward L. Thomas na Jojiya Brigade ya kasance a ajiye da kyau a baya, ba Pender ko Hill suka kira su don taimakawa ko cin gajiyar ci gaban ba.^[45]Sojojin kungiyar sun ja da baya a jihohi daban-daban na tsari.An ce brigades da ke Seminary Ridge suna tafiya da gangan kuma a hankali, suna ci gaba da gudanar da ayyukansu, duk da cewa ba a sanar da sojojin na Col. Wainwright umarnin ja da baya ba kuma suka sami kansu su kadai.Lokacin da Wainwright ya fahimci halin da yake ciki, sai ya umarci ma'aikatan bindigar da su janye a tafiya, ba ya so ya firgita sojojin kuma su fara cin zarafi.Yayin da matsin lamba ya karu, Wainwright ya umarci sauran bindigoginsa guda 17 su shiga titin Chambersburg, uku.^[46] AP Hill ya kasa yin duk wani ajiyarsa don neman masu kare Seminary, babban damar da aka rasa.^[47]