Bayan jin labarin nasarar da kungiyar ta samu kan zargin Pickett, Brigadier Janar Judson Kilpatrick ya kaddamar da harin dawakai a kan sojojin Longstreet's Corps a kudu maso yammacin Big Round Top.Ƙasar ta kasance da wahala ga wani hari da aka ɗaure saboda yana da ƙaƙƙarfa, da katako mai yawa, kuma yana ɗauke da manyan duwatsu - kuma mutanen Longstreet sun kasance masu ƙarfi tare da taimakon bindigogi.^[119] Birgediya Janar Elon J. Farnsworth ya nuna rashin amincewa da rashin amfanin irin wannan matakin, amma ya bi umarni.An kashe Farnsworth a kashi na hudu cikin biyar na hare-haren da ba a yi nasara ba, kuma rundunarsa ta yi asara mai yawa.^[120] Ko da yake Kilpatrick aƙalla shugaban ƙungiyar ɗaya ya bayyana shi a matsayin "jajirtacce, ɗan kasuwa, da kuzari", al'amura irin su tuhumar Farnsworth sun ba shi laƙabi na "Kill Doki".^[121]